fix: address PR review feedback

Address all reviewer comments from PR #387:

1.  Add unit tests for annotations (tests/server/test_annotations.py)
   - 10 comprehensive test functions validating all annotation patterns
   - Tests for titles, read-only, destructive, idempotent operations
   - Validates specific ADR-017 decisions (webdav write, semantic search)
   - Cross-category consistency checks

2.  Fix nc_webdav_write_file idempotency classification
   - Changed from idempotentHint=False to idempotentHint=True
   - Rationale: Uses HTTP PUT without version control
   - Writing same content to same path = same end state (idempotent)

3.  Fix semantic search openWorldHint inconsistency
   - Changed from openWorldHint=False to openWorldHint=True
   - Rationale: Consistent with other Nextcloud tools
   - Nextcloud is external to MCP server (indexed data is implementation detail)

4.  Update ADR-017 with resolved decisions
   - Converted Open Questions to Resolved Questions
   - Added detailed rationale for webdav write and semantic search
   - Updated status from Proposed to Implemented
   - Added decision timeline with dates

5.  Add MCP Tool Annotations guidelines to CLAUDE.md
   - Comprehensive section with code examples for all patterns
   - Key principles documented (idempotency, destructive, open world)
   - References ADR-017 for detailed rationale

All OAuth tools verified to have proper annotations (oauth_tools.py lines 686-751).
This commit is contained in:
Chris Coutinho
2025-12-11 13:50:55 +01:00
parent e1412320a7
commit 19183ad14a
5 changed files with 280 additions and 11 deletions
+62
View File
@@ -56,6 +56,68 @@ This file provides guidance to Claude Code (claude.ai/code) when working with co
- Pass-through (default): Simple, stateless (ENABLE_TOKEN_EXCHANGE=false)
- Token exchange (opt-in): RFC 8693 delegation (ENABLE_TOKEN_EXCHANGE=true)
### MCP Tool Annotations (ADR-017)
**All tools MUST include annotations** following these patterns:
```python
from mcp.types import ToolAnnotations
# Read-only tools (list, search, get)
@mcp.tool(
title="Human Readable Name",
annotations=ToolAnnotations(
readOnlyHint=True,
openWorldHint=True, # Nextcloud is external to MCP server
),
)
# Create operations
@mcp.tool(
title="Create Resource",
annotations=ToolAnnotations(
idempotentHint=False, # Creates new resources each time
openWorldHint=True,
),
)
# Update operations (with etag/version control)
@mcp.tool(
title="Update Resource",
annotations=ToolAnnotations(
idempotentHint=False, # ETag changes = different inputs
openWorldHint=True,
),
)
# Delete operations
@mcp.tool(
title="Delete Resource",
annotations=ToolAnnotations(
destructiveHint=True, # Permanently deletes data
idempotentHint=True, # Same end state if called repeatedly
openWorldHint=True,
),
)
# HTTP PUT without version control (special case)
@mcp.tool(
title="Write File",
annotations=ToolAnnotations(
idempotentHint=True, # Same content = same end state
openWorldHint=True,
),
)
```
**Key Principles**:
- **Idempotency**: Same inputs → same result. ETags change after updates, making them non-idempotent
- **Destructive**: Operations that permanently delete/overwrite data
- **Open World**: All Nextcloud tools access external service (openWorldHint=True)
- **Titles**: Use human-readable names, not snake_case function names
**See**: `docs/ADR-017-mcp-tool-annotations.md` for detailed rationale and examples
### Project Structure
- `nextcloud_mcp_server/client/` - HTTP clients for Nextcloud APIs
- `nextcloud_mcp_server/server/` - MCP tool/resource definitions